Real Estate

Why Experience Real Estate Is the Last Defensible Square Footage

For thirty years, institutional real estate followed a simple hierarchy: Class A office at the top, prime retail next, industrial and hospitality below. That hierarchy is now inverted, and most portfolios haven’t caught up.

The reason is straightforward. Artificial intelligence and remote work are quietly repricing every square foot in the built environment, and only one category is immune: the square footage that requires a human body to be physically present to derive value. Experience real estate—restaurants, entertainment venues, competitive social, hospitality, immersive retail—is the last defensible footprint left.

The great unbundling of physical space

Office towers were built on the assumption that knowledge work required proximity. That assumption is dead. Not softened—dead. Manhattan office is trading at 40–60% of 2019 marks on the deals that clear. San Francisco is worse. Chicago’s Loop is a slow-motion writedown.

Retail was already unbundling before AI. Amazon took the transactional layer a decade ago. What remained was the “experience of shopping”—and AI-generated personalization, virtual try-on, and same-day delivery are hollowing out even that. When your phone knows your size and preferences better than any store associate, the store’s function collapses to two things: something to do or something to feel. If it’s neither, it’s a warehouse with a lease.

Industrial and logistics have held up because AI accelerates e-commerce demand, but that space is functionally invisible. Nobody chooses it, nobody feels it, nobody talks about it. It’s already priced.

That leaves one category where AI makes the asset more valuable, not less.

The physics of experience

Experience venues share a property no software can strip out: the value is generated in the room.

You cannot Zoom into F1 Arcade with your friends and have it feel like F1 Arcade. You cannot AI-generate the sound of a Puttshack ball dropping into a lit target while your college roommate hits a hole-in-one and buys the next round. You cannot stream the smell of a wood-fired kitchen at hour three of a great dinner with people you love.

These are not features that a better product can replicate. They are the product.

This isn’t sentimentality—it’s economics. When the marginal cost of digital replication approaches zero, the only assets that hold pricing power are the ones digital replication cannot touch. Experience real estate is the physical instantiation of scarcity in a world where scarcity is disappearing everywhere else.

Three tailwinds compounding at once

1. Time reallocation. Remote and hybrid work returned 2–3 hours per weekday to knowledge workers. That time is not going into more streaming—Netflix numbers say the opposite. It’s going into third places: gyms, restaurants, competitive social, boutique fitness, entertainment. Categories up 20–40% year over year while traditional bars decline. This is a permanent demand shift, and it lands directly on experience venues.

2. Loneliness as a market force. The U.S. Surgeon General declared loneliness a public health emergency in 2023. Gen Z reports the lowest in-person social engagement of any cohort ever measured. The counter-move is already visible: run clubs, pickleball, competitive socializing, communal dining—categories growing 20–40% year over year. People will pay a premium to be around other people doing something together. That premium accrues to the operator and the landlord.

3. AI-driven productivity releases discretionary capital. As AI compresses cost structures across services, professional labor, and creative work, the winners will spend the surplus. History says they don’t spend it on more spreadsheets. They spend it on time, experience, and status. The last thirty years of luxury spending compounded on goods; the next thirty compound on experiences. Capital markets have not yet priced this.

What “defensible” actually means

Defensibility in real estate has always meant one of three things: irreplaceable location, regulatory moat, or operating complexity. Experience venues stack all three.

  • Location: you cannot rebuild Miami Beach, Mayfair, or Wrigleyville. Great experience real estate is location-locked in a way an office building never was.
  • Regulatory: liquor licenses, entertainment permits, capacity restrictions, and zoning create real barriers to entry. In most major markets, license counts are fixed or grow slower than population.
  • Operating complexity: running a great venue is a craft business. Software eats generic operations; it does not eat hospitality culture, service standards, or the taste of the person choosing the music. The best operators compound over decades.

Why institutional capital is missing it

Walk into any pension, endowment, or sovereign wealth fund’s real estate allocation and you’ll see the same four buckets: Class A office, grocery-anchored retail, multifamily, industrial. That framework was built between 1995 and 2015. It has not been rewritten. And it is now structurally wrong on three fronts at once.

Mistake #1: Experience is slotted as “other.” Hospitality and entertainment sit in the “alternative” sleeve, 2–5% of a real estate allocation, treated as opportunistic side bets. That framing dates to a period when experience venues were operationally messy and hard to underwrite at scale. That period is over. Puttshack, F1 Arcade, Topgolf, Life Time, Equinox Hotels, Soho House—these are institutional-scale platforms with unit economics that dwarf a suburban strip center. The allocation buckets haven’t been redrawn to hold them.

Mistake #2: They underwrite real estate, not operating businesses. Institutional RE teams are trained on cap rates, lease terms, and tenant credit. Experience real estate is operating real estate—the return isn’t the rent, it’s the enterprise value of the operator inside the four walls. That requires unit-level P&L, brand equity, concept life-cycle risk, cohort retention. Most RE teams don’t have this muscle. Their PE teams do, but PE and RE sit in different silos with different mandates. Experience falls in the seam.

Mistake #3: They are anchored to marks they can’t take. Every large allocator is sitting on office and Class B retail marks not yet written to reality. Taking those marks is a career-defining act most CIOs cannot politically absorb in a single cycle. So the exposure stays, the rotation delays, and capital that should be moving into the next twenty years of demand is trapped in the last twenty years of supply.

The pattern is not new

Every generational shift in real estate looks the same:

  • 1970s: Institutions underweight suburban office. Specialists got rich.
  • 1990s: Underweight big-box retail and industrial REITs. Specialists got rich.
  • 2000s: Underweight data centers, cell towers, self-storage. Specialists got rich.
  • 2020s: Underweight experience.

The specialists building it will get rich. The institutions will follow—five to ten years late, at prices set by everyone who moved first.

The portfolio implication

At EMERGING, our thesis has been consistent: hospitality, restaurants, entertainment, and experience-driven retail are not a niche within real estate. They are the surviving core of it. The rest of the built environment is being repriced downward by software. Experience is being repriced upward by everything software cannot do.

The best real estate story of the next decade is not going to be a data center or a warehouse. It’s going to be a room full of people who chose to be there, paying for something they can only get by showing up.

That’s the last defensible square footage. And it’s still available.


Mathew Focht is Founding Managing Partner of EMERGING, a growth equity firm and concept development platform focused on hospitality, restaurants, entertainment, and experience-driven retail. Portfolio includes Puttshack, F1 Arcade, Flight Club, Batbox, Blue Sushi, and Silverspot Cinema.

Author:
Categories:
Real Estate
Tags:
  • Subscribe to our latest insights

Are you capital raise ready?